Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Dancing With The Stars
Bitter But Brilliant > TELEVISION > Reality TV

Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7
potmeetskettle
Mario Lopez is so skeevy.
Eris Rising
And in response to the subtitle, may I just add "You call those stars?"
Flahdagal
You may, but it smacks a lot of MissAlllie's (TV Guide?) piece where she invented "Dancing" "With" "the" "Stars", which is moderately funny, but she can keep her honking non-dancing tootsies off my show, thanks.

PMK, were you baiting the Gator?
Eris Rising
I was actually going for a give-and-take I remember from my Rocky Horror days.

FRANK: I've been making a man...

AUDIENCE: You call that a man?

FRANK: With blonde hair and a tan...

AUDIENCE: You call that a tan?

Speaking of which, I want to start a write-in campaign to have the Time Warp as one of the dances next season.

Magpie
I've been casting all my online votes each week for Emmitt and Cheryl, mainly because I adore Cheryl. Tonight, I voted the same way, but it was just as much for Emmitt this time around, because he was fabulous! I love it that he not only dances well, but he seems to be enjoying the dance as opposed to worrying about what he looks like on camera (MARIO).

I bet Emmitt would rock the Time Warp.
Gatorbait
I'm just bemused that on a show that featured Tony Dovolani, Tucker with an F Carlson, Joey Lawrence's eyebrows, AND that doyen of the trailer park, Jerry Springer, Mario Lopez gets singled out as so skeevy. But to each his/her own.

Emmitt was good, definitely the best of the night with his mambo, but I think he, and Mario last week, were really well served by getting a true mambo song. I don't know the name of Emmitt's song, but as soon as I heard the beginning of "Ran Kan Kan" last week, I knew it would be a hot dance. Too bad they didn't feature the vocals.

Emmitt really has a lot of natural grace and a fluidity to his movements that I almost forget just how muscular he is. It is a lot of fun to watch him dance because he's charming and Cheryl's a sweetheart, who's also a great dancer, and they just bring so much joy to their dances.

Mario and Karina bring a different vibe entirely, but I find it just as entertaining to watch. They're sexy and live wires and it's all very kinetic between them. They bristle with energy and he really is the class of the field as a dancer. I thought their fox trot was fun and flirty and every bit the equal of Emmitt's mambo.

As for the rest, Joey gets a lot of assists from the very presence of Edyta's legs. You almost forget he's even there because, damn. And she's constantly showing them off to their best advantage. I only wish the show went with Perez Prado's original arrangement of "Mambo #5" instead of that crap Louie Bega version. It's so much more mambo-y with all the brass.
Kitty Foyle
It seemed like they've all been reading their press because Mario was animated during the judging and Joey referred to his lip-licking habit and Jerry actually tried this week. I liked all the dances last night, though I might have missed a lot, because I was on the phone. There are some really good dancers left (plus Jerry), but this season just doesn't amaze me. I thought Drew and Cheryl were pretty amazing, but while these dances are enjoyable, I'm just not loving it this season.
DodgerGirl
Poor Monique, I thought we were going to have another flashing last night! I hope that's the repeat dance so they have another chance, but I'm guessing it will be Cheryl and Emmitt, who were both very good.

Surprisingly, I really really enjoyed watching Joey dance last night. Carrie Anne was right, he really did look like he was enjoying himself on the mambo. I don't know why Edyta gets the suckiest dress designs, though. It's like they're putting sheer dress panels on her and belting them. Bah.
Magpie
I was pretty amazed at how well Monique handled getting her shoe heel caught in her dress during her first dance. That had to suck, doing those steps with feathers under her foot. I would've given her a 10 just for her poise.
Eris Rising
Now that Jerry's taking it more seriously, I'm not finding him as interesting. Impressed with the talent, sure, but it doesn't measure up to his competitors. The amusement factor isn't there as much now.
DodgerGirl
Interview with Cheryl Burke
woodstove
Sara got her foot caught during her disaster of a Paso too. Her's was caught for most of the dance too. I kept watching it and wondering if she would fall. I think that was part of why it sucked.

I just like all of them. The season isn't wowing me though. They all seem nice, so I don't know why I am not all that riveted.

Monique may be gone this week. She does well, but again, no real pull for me, except her amazingly fearless moves. I think her costumes suck, and don't show her or her moves off. Her "sexy" dance outfit for the "dance of love" looked like a white girdle and granny bra, feathers or no, and it cut her in half and ruined the showing off of the hip movement. Last nights were a bit better, but I think her performances are really under-rated and blah because of the consistantly odd music, and the horrid clothes. Someone on TWOP said they watched a few of her dances using Mario's music and they just sparkled, Samba seemed more like Samba, etc.

I like Mario, but he seems to get the best music, generally got to go near last or last in the beginning, and is a ballet trained (and who knows what else!) ringer. Add that to the way the judges push him as the next coming and it bugs me. I still think he's the best out there.

Jerry just charms me, and great choice of music for his fox trot! "My way" was a great way to go out, if he goes out this week.

Emmit is a joy to watch, and more of a natural dancer. If he had Mario's training he would be the stand-out here, so for that reason, I think he "should" win it.

Joey seems sweet, and sometimes sparkles, but he has this "loooosey-gooosey" body, head, and arm movement that just takes me out of the magic almost everytime.

Last, if no one is doing a heel lead, and that's what the dance calls for, (whatever the hell it means) then they do NOT deserve 10's!

Edited to fix crap, and also because I want to say that I am sick of Edyta's costumes. Vary it up a bit! I am sick of your bikini with fabric strips flailing around.
Flahdagal
QUOTE ( "woodstove"+)
Last, if no one is doing a heel lead, and that's what the dance calls for, (whatever the hell it means) then they do NOT deserve 10's!

You can bet in a real world dance competition you would get marked down. But so would Kym totally missing that heel turn in the foxtrot. What I want to know is how the judges can say there were NO heel leads unless they never looked up from the contestant's feet.

I can't count the times I've seen that heel-caught-in-the-fishline-hem thing happen. Poor Monique. Between that and the shaky Paso, she may go. (Paso works against the whole "bodies in motion" rule, in that if you have more than 1% body fat you can't stop as crisply as you should to make it look sharp.)

Yes, Gatorbait, you're right, skeevy is relative. I call Jerry's show the White Trash Cavalcade, but he comes across as avuncular and wholesome here. Go figure.
woodstove
Note, I would love Edyta's costumes if they all didn't look alike. For example, I thought the fabric strips / bikini look was perfect for the "dance of love." They just are beginning to bug me because they don't "add" to the dance's story, and they all look alike. Boring, as stunningly georgeous as she is.
roseland
I do not get how the scoring system works. As noted above, you have judge's complaining about a lack of a required step and giving out 10s. You also have Jerry Springer, who is trying but is just so far below everyone else and he's getting a 7 from judge's who are giving other contestants an 8. How in the hell can he only be 1 point below any of the other contestants? I would love to know exactly how the scoring system works. I'm not making any accusations, honestly. I just don't understand why Jerry Springer is not getting 4s and 5s.
Flahdagal
And if they're only going to use the 7, 8, 9 and 10, then it's a FOUR POINT scale.
woodstove
P got a 4 once I think, but I agree, use the damn range, and FIVE should mean "hit all the basics, enjoyable performance".

Gatorbait
Aside from the fact that the judges need to be less generous with the scoring, I don't think Monique is in any real danger this week specifically because of the judges scoring.

After last year's fiasco with P, they no longer rank the competitors, but assign a percentage to the number of points a contestant receives out of the total points awarded as well as a percentage of the total vote. So, out of a total of 388 points awarded last night, Jerry received 64, or 16.5%. Monique received 77 points, or 19.8%. So for Jerry to beat out Monique, he'd have to receive at least 3.3% more votes this week. That's not taking into account the percentage difference between Jerry and Monique last week.

So it's feasible that she could lose, and them showing her complaining that the judges are tougher on her won't play well with the audience, but I don't think it will happen. I'm pretty certain Jerry goes tonight.
Magpie
I didn't watch tonight's show (can't miss ANTM, after all) but DodgerGirl kindly informed me that Jerry was finally sent packing. I'm betting he's thrilled. I'll kind of miss him, because he was so unlike how I thought he'd be that he was kind of fascinating, but his high point on the show was the waltz and that's all he claimed to be there for, anyway.

My prediction for next week is that Joey will go.
woodstove
I liked his Fox Trot a LOT.

Good about Jerry though.

Gatorbait
Next week depends on the dances. I think it's either Joey or Monique. Last woman left or not, she's not that engaging. It's like she and Louis are doing the same dance but not together. And I think she's doing herself a disservice to have complained two weeks in a row about the big, mean judges. Especially since each of the men left have all been taken to task for poor/illegal performances and they didn't slam the judges for being hard on them. Audience votes are fickle and they don't like sass. Just as Vanessa Olivarez.

But either way, it's not like a final two of Emmitt & Mario wasn't predictable back in the first week. And I'll be very happy with that.
woodstove
I just figured out what I don't like about Joey's dancing. He seems to do the woman's moves. (The flaunt of his hands, the set of his shoulders during some "poses", he would look really nice as the female 1/2 rather than the lead.) I wonder if this is Edyta's inability to teach a GUY's part?

Damn, I said that poorly, but I decided to watch the Mambo picturing him in a feathered gown and Edyta as Max, and dang if Joey's moves weren't excellent!
He's absorbed too many of Edyta's mannerisms.
Kitty Foyle
woodstove, that is hilarious...and you're right. Maybe Joey and Mario could dance together huh.gif
Gatorbait
No one mentioned that Alec came back. Man, that man is a Gumby. It was becoming a bit difficult to watch him swivel every joint on his body simultaneously. I mean, it's a neat parlor trick, but a little disconcerting.

But he and Edyta are a ridiculously attractive couple and they dance well together, when he's not doing that swivel thing, and it's always nice to see the pros really dance.
roseland
Yeah, you never realize how much the pros are holding back until they dance together.

Jerry Springer seemed to be the only one happy to see him leaving. I know Monique is the only woman left (and I know this because she mentions it every other sentence) but I would much rather have the final 3 be all the men. They're just more interesting dancers to me.

I have to say the segment about the men was a little off-putting. The whole emphasis on how these are manly men who are definitely not gay or effeminate in any way -- hey! look at them watching football! So not gay! Mario especially seemed to want to hammer home the fact that the fact that he's a good dancer should not in any way make you think that he couldn't take you in a bar fight!
Flahdagal
They even dragged Emmitt into that "real man" thing. Yeah, so a lot of them are straight. Some aren't. Just like in, you know, life and all.

(Here's one of the things I like about the pros. You know the old space race joke between Russia and the US? "Our Germans our better than your Germans?" In ballroom, the joke is -- even if it says Ivan Storchesky, Newark, New Jersey -- our Russians are better than your Russians.)
henry
Hi Monique? Enough with bitching about how you're working so much harder than the men. Cause for the most part this is partner dancing - so the men and women are pretty much side by side for most of the routines.
Gatorbait
I always thought her gripe was that the guys got passes when they didn't follow the rules, like when Tucker with an F sat in a chair for 3/4 of his first dance...and got the lowest score and booted. Or when Mario did that one, stupid, illegal move during his tango and...got 7s instead of the 10s the judges said they'd HAVE given him if he followed the rules. Or that time that Joey did the lift with Edyta and...he too got much lower scores because of his illegal moves.

Yeah, she's right. The men have never been held accountable for their slips and mistakes.
henry
yeah, she really needs to get over Tucker Carlson and the whole "other dancer(s) were sitting! In chairs! While I was doing splits!" He's gone, you're not, what's your point?
Kitty Foyle
Miss Alli has weighed in that Emmit and Cheryl's Rumba was not "all that." Well, I loved it. I was fanning myself afterwards and I said to my husband that it looked like they were having sex. And apparently there is some question of where Cheryl's hand landed at one point. I guess I'm a dork and I KNOW I don't know beans about ballroom dancing, but geez, it made me happy. But I don't dare post my thoughts you know where wink.gif
preciosa
QUOTE
And apparently there is some question of where Cheryl's hand landed at one point.
It landed exactly where you think it landed.

I get where Monique is coming from. It's almost clear that the judges have their favourites and she's not one of them. Even when they denigrate Mario for lack of actual steps and stuff like that, they still get 8s and 9s. After all of the complicated stuff that Monique does and never gets rewarded (case in point the wicked awesome step sequence across th floor during last night's tango), she's bound to feel put out.
henry
Her hand landed, rested, and stayed for a really really long time
Gatorbait
QUOTE (davitt+Nov 1 2006, 06:02 AM)
I get where Monique is coming from. It's almost clear that the judges have their favourites and she's not one of them. Even when they denigrate Mario for lack of actual steps and stuff like that, they still get 8s and 9s. After all of the complicated stuff that Monique does and never gets rewarded (case in point the wicked awesome step sequence across th floor during last night's tango), she's bound to feel put out.

But she also doesn't have to learn to lead the dance which the men do. She has a built in advantage of having a showboating pro throwing her around and leading her through those complicated steps. And that tango was a hot mess. The steps were so complicated that it took all her effort just to try to get them right, and most of the time she wasn't. Part of ballroom dancing is that the dancers move have to be in sync and she looked like she was trying not to step on Louis's toes half the time.

Len was on the right track about competitive diving but his ultimate point was wrong because competitive divers have to do exactly what they asked Louis and Monique to do, which is balance the difficulty level with her actual ability to complete the steps. Louis keeps creating these difficult dances that Monique can barely learn so she ends up looking, and performing, worse than the other dancers. I think the judges criticism of her is more than fair, but she and Louis just aren't hearing it. It really IS better to do a less complex routine flawlessly than to attempt a very complicated one half-assedly.

Mario and Karina have some fairly intricate footwork as well, but it looks less complicated because he's better able to execute it, and in sync with Karina. But I will say that when he broke the rules those two weeks in a row, he was also given 7s, which is slightly lower than what Monique got when she got called for not doing a samba and much lower than Emmitt's 25 for basically breaking the exact same rules Mario did when they both did the fox trot. Great performance, not a fox trot. So I also think Monique is off on that criticism because as the series has gone on, the judges have become less punitive with the rule-breaking.

As for Emmitt & Cheryl's rumba, I think most of the dance was Cheryl and Emmitt swayed a lot. It was sexy, but because she's such a smooth and sexy dancer and that dress was even hotter than Edyta's weird paso costume. I've said before that he's a very graceful and fluid mover which makes even his non-dancing look like dancing, and the rumba by it's very nature is going to be hot, but as far as actual dancing, he was okay but she was incredible.

Monique is the weakest competitor at this point. And it's not that she can't dance, it's that Louis is creating far too difficult dances for her and her performances are suffering for it. It's a pity because they're both entertaining, but Louis needs to take a page from Cheryl's playbook and realize that the way to win is not to be the tricksiest dancer on the floor, but working with your partner's strengths and weaknesses to create memorable dances. Even their cha cha, with all that praise, didn't have any kind of Latin rhythm to it. It was just trick swivel shimmy trick.
roseland
QUOTE
I said to my husband that it looked like they were having sex
Yeah, I'm convinced that Cheryl has more than a bit of a crush on Emmitt. I don't remember her sliding up against Drew the way she slides up against Emmitt while waiting for the scores.

I pretty much agree with what Gatorbait said. My only other comment is that Joey and Edyta should have been given a couple of extra points for having to perform the tango to the theme from the Addams Family. And they managed to make it work. How the hell did they end up with that awful music?
Flahdagal
QUOTE
Monique is the weakest competitor at this point. And it's not that she can't dance, it's that Louis is creating far too difficult dances for her and her performances are suffering for it. It's a pity because they're both entertaining, but Louis needs to take a page from Cheryl's playbook
<br>The last four competitors are all good....every one deserves to be in the last four, IMO. And I totally agree with what you're saying above. Emmitt's rumba was simple and well executed, compared to Monique's tango which was overly complicated and poorly executed. That said, I think Emmitt's portion of the routine, while engaging, was tooo simple. They wouldn't have allowed Joey or Mario to do a routine that basic.

But roseland I disagree with the crush part. Cheryl "clicked" with Drew last season, too. I think any guy that is lucky enough to get paired with Cheryl ends up getting painted with the sexy/engaging/lovable brush. She knows how to interact with her partners on the dance floor and how to choreograph them to their best advantage.

Mario, Emmitt, Joey, Monique. That's my call.

(Yes, gatorbait, I still think he's a little intense, but Mario is dancing at pro level, well beyond anything we've seen to this point. When someone who hasn't seen the show before asks, "which one is the pro?", it's a pretty good indicator.)
roseland
I don't know, Flahdagal. I agree that Cheryl and Drew "clicked". I was talking more about the time when they weren't dancing. Cheryl always seems to be much more willing to give full body hugs and lean against Emmitt than I remember her doing with Drew. I'm not accusing her of anything. I think it's harmless. I mean, the guy has a great body, and he looks damn sexy when he's dancing. I'd try to press up against that body if I were Cheryl, too.
Kitty Foyle
QUOTE (roseland+Nov 1 2006, 11:12 AM)
I'd try to press up against that body if I were Cheryl, too.
Me too. Carrie Ann(sp?) said, "The men want to dance like you and the women want to dance with you." I agree. Emmit is just damn sexy when he dances.
Flahdagal
QUOTE (roseland+Nov 1 2006, 02:12 PM)
I mean, the guy has a great body, and he looks damn sexy when he's dancing. I'd try to press up against that body if I were Cheryl, too.
No argument there!
Gatorbait
QUOTE (Flahdagal+Nov 1 2006, 10:27 AM)
I still think he's a little intense, but Mario is dancing at pro level, well beyond anything we've seen to this point. When someone who hasn't seen the show before asks, "which one is the pro?", it's a pretty good indicator.
I noticed this when they showed that brief clip from the samba. I'm a novice, so correct me if I'm wrong, but it really looked like he was leading Karina through that [Portuguese-named move that ends in "fogo"] portion and they were just spot on. Their body positions and footwork just flowed and nothing looked forced.

I do agree with Carrie Ann that he needs to work on his transitions. There's an element of "Look at what I can do" to some of his dances. Which is why the waltz was such a surprise. It seemed that with a less showy dance he was forced to focus on the dance as a whole instead of fancy individual moves.

Emmitt's my second choice and sentimental favorite, though. Got to love a Gator, and he was such a class act in Dallas when the whole team was a ball of sleaze. He's just always been such a great guy.
DodgerGirl
I'm so bummed that Monique and Louis were booted last night. That's really all I have to say.
woodstove
She got a bad edit too, I am sure most "stars" can get caught saying something icky, like her mini-rant about the unfair scoring. Why show that? It seemed mean of ABC. Her partner is surly, (frankly, I don't blame him, but it's stupid on this show to want "quality") and I think that wore off on her.

If the show isn't scoring based on difficulty, then, what the hell? Just go out there and do a few basics, look cool, and get 9's and 10's? Frankly, I would rather see some chances taken, and hear the judges actually comment on specifics of the dance that were well done, or very difficult, and reward for that.

Revising the scoring may be the way to go here.
Difficulty/ Technique
Presentation


I like watching this show, partly because it's friendly, partly because of Tom, and mostly because I am learning a bit about dance. I don't want to see never ending pretend dance, with no "reach" for higher levels of skill or difficulty.

Mario is a ringer. He's adorable, but he hasn't "grown" as a dancer here. He came in with all of that. He's the best, but I hope he doesn't win, because he was already the best--no growth, no challenge. Blech. His dances all blur together for me though, same snappy moves, over and over some more. No "ahhh" moments for me, ala Drew though.

Joey's has unfortunate "girly" expression, very "Edtya" in nature, but that's poor teaching or his chameleon behavior. I have that too when learning something new, so I sympathise, it's hard to not mirror your partner when absorbing stuff. I do it with accents/language so I get it. Edtya should have brought a guy in for him to emulate, because that is the only part of Joey's dancing that bugs me, but it's a biggie. He has the worst teacher of those remaining, so I will not be unhappy if he wins it. He won't though.

Emmit is my surprise "hope he wins it" pick. He just has constantly improved, uses his body so well, and he's older, thicker, and less of a "natural" here--yet he still delivers. His dances are smooth and classy and enjoyable. His feet seem to be his worst thing, but I don't care, I like the rest.

So, if difficulty doesn't matter to the judges, give it to Emmit. If it does, why did you diss Monique? If you want a balance of growth and difficulty--it should be Joey's.

This season just was not as good.
weejie
You know, I kinda like this season. I do think last season was better, but I won't be unhappy to see any one of the final three win. I think I would have been very angry last season if Jerry Rice had won, even though I like him. He just didn't have the moves and the grace that Drew had. But this season, I truly admire the skills of all three finalists, I think they each deserve to win.
Gatorbait
QUOTE (woodstove+Nov 2 2006, 09:02 AM)
So, if difficulty doesn't matter to the judges, give it to Emmit.  If it does, why did you diss Monique?  If you want a balance of growth and difficulty--it should be Joey's.

So being the best overall dancer doesn't count?

It's not that difficulty doesn't matter, none of the judges said that, it's that execution counts more than difficulty. Just like in diving. If a diver can perform a dive with a 3.1 degree of difficulty for 8.5-9.0 he's better off performing that dive than one with a 3.4 degree of difficulty that he can only score 7.0-7.5 on because in the end the final score will be lower despite the greater difficulty.

Same with Monique. Louis had her doing all these tricks that she could barely learn, let alone master, and she looked worse for it. He could have even kept one or two of his flashier tricks in each dance, but it's like his ego got a hold of him and he kept exponentially increasing the difficulty and Monique just wasn't able to keep up. And dancing isn't just being able to perform the intricate footwork, it's about transitions and physical grace and fluid, beautiful body lines and posture. Monique had very little of that in the last few weeks because she was so hellbent on performing all the flash and tricks that Louis threw into the routines.

It's too bad that she faltered, but it's not the capriciousness of the judges or the fact that they don't care about difficulty. It was the very uneven partnership between the two where Louis kept demanding more from her and she never pointed out to him that he was asking too much.
woodstove
I just thought her dancing was more than "tricks." Her footwork was very complicated and fast, at least it felt that way to me. There is no way that Emmit's is nearly as complicated as hers. Yes, I liked Emmits better, but did it deserve a higher score? Hard to say...

That's why I think there should be two scores. It might balance things out a bit.

As far as the best dancer winning, good question. I don't know. Mario is the best, but then he's a trained dancer. Emmit obviously never danced professionally before and he's grown the most on the show. Joey is really good, has steadily improved, but suffered from a bad teacher that seemed to teach him feminine dance style, and did the high-kick splits a lot.

I am not unhappy with the final 3, anyone of them could win this and, depending on how you look at it, it would be "fair."

Personally, I am just not a fan of "ringers" who can already do complicated moves competing with novices. I wish they didn't allow anyone with significant previous dance training to compete.

Sticking with the diving analogy, which actually has zip to do with the way the dances are judged, since diving does use two scores, and this show does not, Mario would win every single dive. Why? Because in diving, degree of difficulty DOES count, and he has been "diving" for years, knows how to present, knows how to twirl, leap, snap his feet, etc. etc. Monique, Joey, and Emmit all had to learn basics, so I give them a heck of a lot more credit.

That's what bugged me about Stacy last year too. It's not that she wasn't good, because she certainly was. It was that she was obviously starting at a much different level than the others that bugged.

I guess I wish they left the ringers out, certainly anyone with years of ballet or tap or other styles of dance training, even if it's not ballroom. Or, if they want to include them, have them all in the same season. That would be kind of fun, and the dancing would be great, since the learning curve would start at a higher level for all of them.





Gatorbait
Fair enough. I like the ringers because they can dance, so there's no sitting in chairs and stomping around.
woodstove
Now you have me thinking about a "ringer" season. I think it would be really good. They could bill it as "they may know how to dance, but can they ballroom dance?!" or something.

People like:

Talk Show Host: Kelly Ripa (former pro TV teen dancer)

Acadamy Award Winner: Goldie Hawn (former go-go dancer with years of training)

Wrestler: Stacy Keibler (sp?) who studied ballet!

TV heart throb, Mario Whateverhislastnameis who has studied dance for years!

Movie star: Jennifer Grey, she learned to dirty dance, but can she ballroom live?

Ballet Dancer: Barishnokov, but can he rumba?

Movie Icon: Jennifer Beals, but is she all flash?

Former Broadway Original Chorus Line dancer: Some Guy, but does he still have what it takes?

Throw in a young hip hopper, or rocker who dancers, actually, throw in some young anybodies because I can only think of old people here!

It might be fun for a season.
preciosa
QUOTE
Wrestler: Stacy Keibler (sp?) who studied ballet!
Ballet training and ballroom training are two different animals because ballroom is the antithesis of amost everything that you learn in ballet. The only thing ballet can help you with in ballroom (and we've heard the judges say it) is the actual form/posture - that kind of thing.

And didn't Stacy do ballet when she was a kid? Not like she grew up to be a professional dancer.
Gatorbait
And Mario's last name is Lopez. It's not that difficult.
DodgerGirl
QUOTE (woodstove+Nov 2 2006, 09:26 PM)
I just thought her dancing was more than "tricks." Her footwork was very complicated and fast, at least it felt that way to me. There is no way that Emmit's is nearly as complicated as hers.
With the tango that Monique and Louis performed, it looked to me that if they had had a couple of more days of practice, it would have been perfect and fantastic. It always looked to me like Monique wanted to push harder and wasn't being forced by Louis to do a complicated routine.
woodstove
Sorry, I honestly just blanked on Mario's name. I couldn't have told you Joey's or Monique's either. Actually, I only recognised a couple of dancer's names this season, Mario, Joey, Monique were just a few I never heard of.

Ballet spins and twirls and balance and extensions, finding the beat, feeling the music, and being able to point toes, use arms, already be limber, and just perform in general seem to also be pretty important, not just posture.

I certainly understand enjoying trained dancer's performances on this show. Saying they don't have an tremendous advantage? Nah. I don't buy that. At all.
I don't care what kind of dance they did, it has to help. Studying for more than a few years, kid or not? Advantage.

I just wish it was a a bit more of level playing field, since it is supposedly a "competition." Or a different scoring. Something.

Then there is the age thing too, so...

Still when you get someone who has the age advantage AND the training advantage--what's the point? Duh, they are going to win it, or some popularity vote that has nothing to do with dancing is going to win it. Either one of those outcomes just bugs me a bit.
roseland
QUOTE
It always looked to me like Monique wanted to push harder and wasn't being forced by Louis to do a complicated routine.
Yeah, Monique was going on about how she was there to be an "inspiration" so I think she was fine with how hard Louis was pushing her. He last spiel kind of bugged me. Just because you did the splits doesn't mean you deserved a 10. It seemed to me to point out the flaw in their routines. They weren't concentrating on the entire dance, they were focusing on the big, flashy moments, feeling that the intricate footwork and difficult stunts should be enough. They refused to acknowlege that, if you look awkward doing intricate footwork, it's going to count against you. Cheryl seems to have figured it out when she told Emmitt "No, you look bad doing that. You must always look good." Cheryl understands that no matter how complicated a sequence is, if your celebrity looks bad doing it, it's going to get lower points. And it's not just the stuff Monique stumbled over because of the difficulty. There were some dance moves, like that popping stuff they incorporated into the dance, that just made Monique look awful. She looked like she was in the midst of an epileptic seizure. Louis is not taking any time to figure out what moves look better on Monique. She does not have the slim fluidness that a lot of these dances seem to require in order to look "right." He should be working with that in the way that Cheryl works with Emmitt.
QUOTE (->
QUOTE
It always looked to me like Monique wanted to push harder and wasn't being forced by Louis to do a complicated routine.
Yeah, Monique was going on about how she was there to be an "inspiration" so I think she was fine with how hard Louis was pushing her. He last spiel kind of bugged me. Just because you did the splits doesn't mean you deserved a 10. It seemed to me to point out the flaw in their routines. They weren't concentrating on the entire dance, they were focusing on the big, flashy moments, feeling that the intricate footwork and difficult stunts should be enough. They refused to acknowlege that, if you look awkward doing intricate footwork, it's going to count against you. Cheryl seems to have figured it out when she told Emmitt "No, you look bad doing that. You must always look good." Cheryl understands that no matter how complicated a sequence is, if your celebrity looks bad doing it, it's going to get lower points. And it's not just the stuff Monique stumbled over because of the difficulty. There were some dance moves, like that popping stuff they incorporated into the dance, that just made Monique look awful. She looked like she was in the midst of an epileptic seizure. Louis is not taking any time to figure out what moves look better on Monique. She does not have the slim fluidness that a lot of these dances seem to require in order to look "right." He should be working with that in the way that Cheryl works with Emmitt.
Still when you get someone who has the age advantage AND the training advantage--what's the point? Duh, they are going to win it, or some popularity vote that has nothing to do with dancing is going to win it.
I don't think that was the case in Season 2. Stacey didn't win it despite her training. In fact, she came in third. Now I agree there's no way Lynn Swann should have been No. 2 but Drew was not a ringer, did not have a large fan base and he won.
woodstove
Drew was just amazing and that was a great season (to me) partly because the relatively untrained (Drew) was just so very good, and had such a great teacher that he won it. Jerry was there because of popularity. Stacy was excellent.

I agree that Cheryl really plays to her dancer's strengths. I just love the way she shows them off, expects them to rise to it, and finds what works. She's my favorite pro (for this show.) I also completely agree that Louis has no idea how to choreograph for the competition part of this show. What I don't know is how much of that is his fault, and how much of it is the odd, completely subjective, and unknown scoring criteria the judges are using.
Flahdagal
QUOTE (davitt+Nov 3 2006, 07:58 AM)

Ballet training and ballroom training are two different animals because ballroom is the antithesis of amost everything that you learn in ballet. The only thing ballet can help you with in ballroom (and we've heard the judges say it) is the actual form/posture - that kind of thing.
Best ballroom dancer by FAR in my general circle of friend and competitors? A former ballet dancer. And I've heard judges say just the opposite. That's anecdotal, not empirical evidence, but there ya go. Dancing is a highly subjective sport. (If it were just a matter of getting around the floor quickly, we could call it NasDance.)

To me, the difficulty 'vs' performance aspect lies squarely in the lap of the pro. If you've set your amateur partner up to fail, then you deserve to go home. Even if failing means you've reached higher or took more chances or danced a more complicated routine than those that succeeded.

Do I think the show would benefit from a more diverse scoring system? Sure, sounds like a great idea.
Flahdagal
QUOTE (roseland+Nov 3 2006, 12:04 PM)
Louis is not taking any time to figure out what moves look better on Monique. She does not have the slim fluidness that a lot of these dances seem to require in order to look "right." He should be working with that in the way that Cheryl works with Emmitt.
double post. so sue me.

Maybe it's telling that none of Louis' pro partners have had more that 0.005% body fat and were all super-achievers.

QUOTE
there's no way Lynn Swann should have been No. 2 but Drew was not a ringer, did not have a large fan base and he won.
<br>You mean Jerry Rice? What am I missing...who is Lynn Swann?
Gatorbait
Lynn Swann was the Jerry Rice of the 70s. Now he's running for governor of Pennsylvania.
roseland
Yeah, sorry. I'm getting my football receivers mixed up.
Magpie
Gee, the scoring tonight wasn't at all fishy...a three-way tie? Eh.

I totally loved Emmitt's waltz. Great song, smooth movement, and an air of class. I think it was my favorite dance of the night. As usual, I threw all my online votes to Emmitt and Cheryl. I can't wait to see what they do in the freestyle!
DodgerGirl
Shenanigans!

dottstar
I too voted for Emmitt and Cheryl. Loved the Cha Cha. I didn't get Joey's rumba or samba as it didn't make me think Latin at all the same with Mario's Latin dance being meh as well. I think I like Emmitt's overall attitude so his dancing makes me happier then the other two, even if a pro tells me Joey and Mario are better at the steps they kill me with the blah personalities.
DodgerGirl
Okay Joey's pants on his first dance were an abomination. What the hell? They looked like they were hiked up to his armpits. I think they forgot to put on his red clown nose and rainbow suspenders.

Hated the Michael Jackson crotch grab by Mario. He's a really great dancer and keeps up with his partner, which is amazing, but I'm still not all that enthralled by him.

Emmitt, on the other hand....woo! Great, great, great all around. He's so nimble and light, and always has this expression on his face like this is the best thing he's ever done. It's very endearing. Plus he's got the Cheryl factor. She just shines up whomever she's partnered with. I kind of hope next season she gets the sacrificial clumsy oaf/old fart to see what she can do with him.
Possalaqua
I thought Mario's tango was the best dance of the night. It was spectacular, so perfect that it almost seemed like a charicature of a tango (says the layperson). If I had taken the effort to vote, it would've had to be for Mario. The "Bad" cha cha cha was a bit creepy though, I'll admit.
Eris Rising
Talking about how much you love Michael Jackson nowadays is a bit like gushing about what a great running back O.J. Simpson was. True, but...not really the comparison you're looking for, you know?
Flahdagal
Exactly. Michael Jackson's voice just has such a cringe factor. Yeah, the music was good, but yeech. I kept waiting for Mario to look up from under the hat and turn into Jacko, and it creeped me.

Mario's tango? Pro. Outrageously good. The only deserver of a perfect score, IMO.

Joey's rumba: Edyta got him to stop leading with his chest, but she still didn't loosen up his hips enough. Compare his hip action to Emmitt's or Tony's. They have a good five inches of travel on him, lateral hip-wise.

The "tour show" jive was cute cute cute.
woodstove
I loved Mario's tango, but I agree with the Jackson/OJ thing. It's a pity because the music is good, and great to dance to, but imitating the crotch pull just slammed home the MJ factor. If he had done his OWN dance to the song I would have liked it more. I don't need to see an MJ wanta be, and frankly, MJ has so many memorable dance performances it is just stupid to try to out-do the original.

The other dances seemed good, but really...I am just not feeling this season.

I don't care who wins it really. (My posts earlier explain all of this so I won't go into it again.) That tango was niiiiiccce though.
henry
I kept waiting for Joey to say "whooooaa!". Why does he still talk like he's 14?
DodgerGirl
I loved that jive number and wow on Harry Hamlin! He was really moving well, much better than when he was dancing on the show itself. I'm thinking this tour might be worth seeing live.
JoJo
Yay! Emmit made it to the finals! Huzzah!
buffyvol
Dang it! I wanted Emmett and Joey to make the finals. I'd have been happy with either on of them winning.
Eris Rising
Shenanigans again. Ties two weeks in a row?
woodstove
Totally. Also, another completely boring show.

Someone on TWoP commented on Mario's light-footed prancing during the paso. So, I watched it again, hey, I am starting to get the hang of concepts such as power, and stepping "through" the floor. Anyway, as much as I enjoyed it, when i watched it again, the poster was right. No "power" in his attractive moves at all. He did prance all over the floor, all through the dance. This is much more noticable without music though.

Also, watching his dances without the music makes them all look the same to me. Same poses, same steps, different beats, but that's it. He's still enjoyable to watch, but, as I have said before, I think he came in to this pretty much at the level that he's going out. He's learned a bit, but really, not so much.

For that reason alone, I would give it to Emmit.

Willa should have taken this one.
Eris Rising
Here's the lesson: If you're a man and you want to win this competition, have sex with your partner offstage, and act like you're having sex with her onstage. This gives enough of a backstage juiciness/onstage "OMG they're hawt"-ness to win the thing.

And he will win the thing.
roseland
Really? Because I think Emmitt will win. They're tied and I guess I just htink Emmitt has the stronger fan base.

I was disappoined in last night. Neither freestyle blew me away. I think Cheryl missed the mark with this one. She incorporated too many lifts and it ruined the flow of the dancing because Emmitt was being so careful because he was worried about hurting her. And Mario's dance was fun but it just seemed similar to everything other thing they've done.
dottstar
Everybody at work seems to want Emmitt to win! I was surprised but only one person had anything negative to say and it was against Cheryl being to huggy with Emmitt. Horrors, the kids saw daddy being hugged by some strange woman. The woman is from NY! That sort of surprised me it's not quite the same as making out or something.
Magpie
YAY!!!!!!!!

I haven't watched the whole show yet, but I caught the end, which was the important part. I'm very pleased.
ladybug
I am thrilled with the results but was less than impressed with the loser's speech at the end. Sour grapes, much?

The winner was a class act all the way!




I am not naming names for those in the Pacific Time Zone.
woodstove
I don't have a link, so I will post the TWoP version. Apparently others confirm this happened. Tacky Mario. Classy Emmitt.

QUOTE
pinetree22
Fanatic


Today @ 9:21 pm
Email ˇ Report ˇ Post #15105
My local ABC 11 o'clock news did a behind the scenes segment with Emmitt and Mario. Mario is NOT happy about losing! Mario told the news reporter "He thought this was supposed to be a dance contest." He also said he was surprised he didn't win, the best dancer should win, and he thought he did it. Emmitt thanked the fans again and said the time they put into the show and into voting helped them win, along with all the hard work he and Cheryl put into the dances each week. When asked which was more important, winning Super Bowls, or winning a dance contest, he said the Super Bowls were in his past and dancing is now.
<a href='http://people.aol.com/people/article/0,26334,1560071,00.html' target='_blank'>Mario inserts foot in mouth some more.
henry
well now I guess I'm glad Mario lost. what a baby. personally I wasn't crazy about his freestyle. And world class dancer? phwww.
DodgerGirl
What was that old saw about true colors showing during adversity? Suck it up, Mario. You lost what is essentially a popularity contest.

Also, Cheryl is the best female dancer. So there!
ActonBell
Now I feel justified in my lifelong dislike of AC Slater.
Eris Rising
I called it!

I called it wrong, but that still counts, right?
buffyvol
QUOTE (DG+)
Also, Cheryl is the best female dancer. So there!

Sing it Sister!
And Karina, be glad your affair only lasted the 16 weeks. At least you didn't marry him.
bellyache
That's weird, because on The Insider today, Mario was saying he doesn't care if he wins or loses. It was just a competition and he was just glad to be there. What a baby. I guess it was more important to him then he lead on.
buffyvol
Emmett and Mario are supposed to be on Jimmy Kimmel tonight. I think he's on at an ungodly hour, so set those Tivos.
woodstove
They will be on Regis and Kelly in the morning too. He apparently has two more chances to soften that bad sport image. Let's see if he takes them, and actually congratulates or praises the winners. Finally.

I doubt Karin could choke out praise for anyone other than herself or Mario, but maybe she will be told to shut it.

More boring behavior:

QUOTE
Meanwhile, Lopez said he's "hanging in there" after coming in second. But, when he hears some people say he's the better dancer, he told Associated Press Radio News "therein lies the irony" because he "thought this was a dance competition" and that "the better dancer should win, if that's the objective."

He said he's not being boastful, but he had the better partner and the more difficult routines.

His dance partner, Karina Smirnoff, is making lemonade out of the lemons of coming in second. She said, "It's better to be second while everyone is saying 'You should have been first,' than be first when everyone says 'You should be second."
Magpie
Hey, Karina? I think that if *everyone* thought you should have been first, you WOULD have been first.
ladybug
Karina needs a STFU enema.
roseland
QUOTE
"therein lies the irony" because he "thought this was a dance competition" and that "the better dancer should win, if that's the objective."
Did Mario not pay attention to the show he was on? This was a show that had Master P on for four rounds and had Jerry Springer on for three rounds longer than he should have been on. It's a combination dance competition/popularity contest. You lost the popularity contest. And now I know why. Also, I'm not ready to concede you were the better dancer. You were the better Latin dancer, yes but I still think Emmitt was better at the ballroom dancing.
indigoblue
I thought Emmitt connected with the audience better, as well. He looked like he was having a blast. That tipped the scales for me. I didn't vote, but I was definitely rooting for Emmitt & Cheryl.
buffyvol
Not to sound too corny, but Emmett's dancing was delightful. Mario's was very good, but he always looked like he was trying to hard. Yes, that's what you do to win, but to me it came across wrong. I think Emmett always came across as being at ease.
To me, the whole point of watching the show was to be entertained.
At our house, we are still fussing about Drew winning over Stacey. I say Drew was more entertaining, Chris says Stacey was the better dancer. She may have been, but Cheryl and Drew were more fun to watch. If I want to watch "real" Ballroom Dancing, I'll watch it on PBS, if it is still on, if I'm going to watch Celebs dancing, I want the one who is doing the best job, combined with the most entertaining to win.
I will take up for Mario a bit, I don't think he means to come across the way he does. I think he is very intense and passionate and just doesn't think before he opens his mouth. I don't think he realises the consequences of his actions half, or more, of the time.
DodgerGirl
QUOTE (buffyvol+Nov 17 2006, 03:47 AM)
I don't think he realises the consequences of his actions half, or more, of the time.
Isn't that the definition of immaturity? I hate the excuse of "passionate personality" for poor behavior.
Eris Rising
I enjoyed Mario's dances more.

That being said, both he and Karina should shut up and go away now.
weejie
QUOTE (DodgerGirl+Nov 17 2006, 05:46 AM)
QUOTE (buffyvol+Nov 17 2006, 03:47 AM)
I don't think he realises the consequences of his actions half, or more, of the time.

Isn't that the definition of immaturity? I hate the excuse of "passionate personality" for poor behavior.
I agree, I think he's acting immaturely. But that isn't exactly a mortal sin, he's still pretty young, so I kind of give him a pass. I think he's much better "technically" than Emmitt, because he has a dancer's body. It's much leaner and more elegant than Emmitt's powerful build. So his moves seem more fluid and graceful to me.

But I'm awfully glad that Emmitt won. He was surprisingly, delightfully good. And I have to say, after the first show I was rooting for him. I didn't expect him to be nearly as entertaining as he was. I just love to watch people dancing difficult dances and obviously having a great time doing it. Go Emmitt and Cheryl!!
woodstove
He still hasn't really congratulated Emmitt either. Not on Kimmel, not on LIVE, not on GMA. He is such a baby.

TWoP has a mini-recap of the Live and Kimmel appearances in the DWTS's thread, and once again, he blew it. Apparently Emmitt didn't even appear with him on Live this morning. Emmitt was on with Cheryl at the beginning of the show. They did talk about his "never having been in a dance studio" before, in a small, and much nicer way, fighting Mario's jealous insistance that they should have won. Mario and Karina were on last.

I guess Emmitt got tired of Mario's petulant bad sportsmanship, especially when M & K were insulting Cheryl.
henry
I dunno, Mario is 33 yrs old - a little old to be excused for baby-like behavior.

And Emmitt is 37.
weejie
QUOTE (henry+Nov 17 2006, 04:25 PM)
I dunno, Mario is 33 yrs old - a little old to be excused for baby-like behavior.

And Emmitt is 37.
Wow, I didn't realize Mario was in his 30's. I guess I still think of him as that kid that was on the show that my kid's loved when they were little. Maybe I should pull my head out of my dinosaur ass and get with the program, huh? wink.gif

But still, I can't get all offended over his immature behavior. I know a lot of people who have a few little "quirks" in their personalities that wouldn't look very nice in the harsh glare of the publicity spotlight. But for the most part, they're still great people, and a pleasure to know.

And like I said, Emmitt and Cheryl won, so YAY!!

I really loved this season. There were some awesome performances by almost everyone that were just pure joy to watch. I can't wait to see the next cycle. And I really can't wait to see if Cheryl manages to turn her next partner into a champion.
henry
Cheryl has got to be paired with a lunk like Tucker Carlson next year - it's not fair that she gets two guys in a row that are good dancers. Of course, who would have guessed that Emmitt Smith could dance!
buffyvol
I hope she gets paired with a lunk and wins again.
roseland
I have to say, I think they thought they were doing that this time. I don't think the producers thought Emmitt Smith had a chance in hell of winning. He had no dance background. I don't think they thought he'd be Master P type material but I think they thought he'd be more Harry Hamilin. They underestimated both Emmitt and Cheryl's abilities.
weejie
QUOTE (roseland+Nov 20 2006, 02:59 PM)
I have to say, I think they thought they were doing that this time. I don't think the producers thought Emmitt Smith had a chance in hell of winning. He had no dance background. I don't think they thought he'd be Master P type material but I think they thought he'd be more Harry Hamilin. They underestimated both Emmitt and Cheryl's abilities.
I have to agree. I certainly didn't expect him to do nearly as well as he did. He was a very pleasant surprise from the very first show. And Cheryl is phenomenal! I can't wait to see how she does with her next partner.
Flahdagal
Cheryl isn't as visually stunning as Karina or Edyta, and yet she conveys both proficiency in dance and connection to the crowd and her partner. She's the perfect partner for this show.
To quit out of "lo-fi" mode and return to the regular forums, please click here.
dizayn.de © 2003 - 2009 - "lo-fi" for InvisionPower Board v1.3